The PrintMagic Alternative That Makes Budgets Go Further
Nadia is our customer education voice, built from the knowledge of our production team, with over 20 years in printing.
PrintMagic lists 50+ products. 4OVER4.COM lists 1,000+ on 60+ stocks, with standard postcards on 14pt Gloss Cover from $16.48 per 50 and standard brochures on 100# Gloss Text from $57.11 per 50, both in 3 business days. The table below compares the two feature by feature.
Small catalog against full press
4OVER4.COM and PrintMagic, feature by feature
| Feature |  |  |
|---|---|---|
| 200 Free Business Cards | Yes, first in USA since 2011 | No |
| Price Match Guarantee | Yes, 110% price match | No |
| 10,000+ Design Templates + Free Online Designer | Yes (Canvs tool) | Limited |
| Free Samples Kit | Yes, physical samples that ship free | No |
| Loyalty Rewards (Earn Coins) | Yes, earn coins on every order | No |
| 100% Satisfaction + On-Time + Quality Guarantees | Yes, 5 guarantees | Limited |
| Same-Day Shipping | Yes, order by 12pm ET | No |
| Total Cards Printed | 10 billion+ | Not publicly shared |
| Businesses Served | 150,000+ | Not publicly shared |
| Projects Completed | 500,000+ | Not publicly shared |
| On-Time Delivery Rate | 99.8% | Not publicly shared |
| Orders Shipping Early | 82% | Not publicly shared |
| Customer Satisfaction (will reorder) | 99% | Not publicly shared |
| Years in Business | 25+ (since 1999) | Not publicly shared |
| Google Rating | 4.8/5 | Read at the source |
| Facebook Rating | 4.7/5 | Read at the source |
| Total Reviews All Platforms | 10,000+ | Read at the source |
| Google Trusted Store | Yes | No |
| Total Standard Products | 1,000+ | 50+ |
PrintMagic posts little public record, so most of its rows read Not publicly shared or Read at the source. Against a quoted price, read the samples kit, the price match and same-day shipping rows first.
Where a short list runs out
Six things a 50-product catalog cannot do
The same postcard on 22 stocks
A standard postcard at 4OVER4.COM can be ordered on 22 stocks, from 10pt StarLustre Platinum to 18pt Premium White Linen or 26pt Metallic Pearl Ice.
Yard signs to door hangers, 1,000+ products
1,000+ products versus PrintMagic's 50+, so the yard signs and door hangers for one promotion go on the same order as the postcards.
Three business days on postcards, flyers and brochures
Standard postcards, flyers and brochures each print in 3 business days, so the date the calculator shows is the date you plan the drop around.
Turnaround priced up front
Faster tiers show their price before checkout, so a rush is a number you choose before you pay.
Canvs and templates at no cost
A tight budget should not pay for design software. Open a flyer or postcard template in Canvs, the free online designer, or download a free print-ready blank template and build in your own tool.
Free cards and coins
New customers get 200 free business cards, and every order earns loyalty coins.
Stock and reorders
Where a cheap stock costs you the reorder
A budget stretches further when the first run does not have to be reprinted. Black business cards run on 32pt to 80pt Midnite Black Uncoated, and 16pt Uncoated with Soft Touch suits a postcard that gets handled.
Color is the second saving. The presses are G7 color profiled, so the flyer and the postcard that carry the same brand red match, and the reorder matches the first batch.
Pricing
500 standard postcards cost $51.62 and 1,000 cost $86.78, under 9 cents a card.
Samples
The free samples kit ships free, so 14pt Gloss Cover and 24pt Ultra Thick can be compared before you choose.
Support
A person answers on 718-932-2700, by phone or SMS, and a free proof comes with every order.
Gains and gaps
What each printer brings to the order
4OVER4.COM
- Specialty finishes as their own products
- Cards up to 80pt
- Same-day shipping by 12pm ET
- Five written guarantees + 110% price match
- Loyalty coins on every order
PrintMagic
- 50+ core products
- Limited finishing options
- Standard turnaround
- No published price match
- No free-cards or loyalty program
Wally explains the switch from PrintMagic
The fastest way to feel the upgrade
PrintMagic keeps a short list. 4OVER4.COM starts new customers with 200 free business cards, then lets the same design move to soft touch, spot UV or 32pt black for the full run.
Order business cards →Price per piece
Postcards at $0.33 each, and three more staples
The long read
PrintMagic and 4OVER4.COM, part by part
PrintMagic keeps its list short. The parts below cover what runs out first, the base price, stock and fit.
What a PrintMagic buyer runs out of first
Paper runs out first, then range: ultra-thick stock, spot UV, foil and the professional design templates for each product are all on the 4OVER4.COM menu. Loyalty coins on every order pay back on the reorder, which PrintMagic does not offer.
What the base price covers
Look past the sticker number and check what comes standard: a free file check, cutting and packaging are in every 4OVER4.COM price.
The ladder does the rest. 5,000 standard postcards cost $139.71, under 3 cents a card, and a lower written quote for the identical product is matched and beaten by 10%.
Stock from 13pt to 80pt
A client feels the stock before reading the card. Classic business cards run on 74 stocks from 13pt to 80pt, with kraft, linen, pearl and cotton among them.
Soft touch cards come in 32pt, 48pt, 64pt and 80pt, from 50 for $40.28. Also weighing label and sticker specialists? See the Avery alternative breakdown.
Who the switch suits
Small business owners who want cards, flyers, labels and signage from one account, and designers who need a finish the printer actually stocks.
Event planners on a fixed date who need the 3 business day postcard. Our guide on how to choose the right online print service lists the rest of the checks.
The verdict
A stronger long-term partner than PrintMagic: more stocks per product, finishes sold as products of their own and a published price match.
Ratings, both printers
4.8 out of 5 from 10,000+ reviews across the catalog
The 4.8 covers every 4OVER4.COM product: Google 4.8 and Facebook 4.7. For PrintMagic, read the dated reviews at the source.
Explore more from 4OVER4.COM
Guides, showcases and the other comparisons
Get Started
Price a first postcard run
Order the free samples kit, then price the same stock and quantity you were quoted at PrintMagic.
Legal Disclaimer
Gold Standard guarantees apply to all standard orders placed through 4over4.com. Price match requires verifiable proof of a competitor's published price for an equivalent product with matching specifications and turnaround time. Satisfaction guarantee covers manufacturing defects and print quality issues. Contact support with order number and documentation.
PrintMagic questions
Common Questions
Six answers for PrintMagic buyers on switching, quality, products, speed, guarantees and files. Every other printing question is on our FAQs hub.
Why should I consider a PrintMagic alternative?
If you need more paper options or a broader catalog than 50+ products: 4OVER4.COM runs 60+ paper types. A price match on any lower written quote keeps the risk of a first order low.
Will my print quality improve if I switch to 4OVER4.COM?
The difference shows most on thicker stocks and finishes: spot UV, soft-touch matte and foil stamping on card stock up to 80pt, rated 4.8 across 10,000+ reviews. If you are also comparing other services, check out the Axiomprint alternative page.
Does 4OVER4.COM offer the same products as PrintMagic?
Yes: business cards, postcards, flyers, banners, labels, stickers, brochures and signage are all here. Add a trackable code to any of them with the free QR code generator.
How fast can 4OVER4.COM deliver my order?
99.8% of orders arrive on time and 82% ship ahead of schedule, and select products can ship the same day when ordered by 12pm ET.
Is there a money-back guarantee if I am not happy?
Yes. The Ultimate Satisfaction guarantee is money back, one of five on every order with quality, price match, on time every time and customer service. The Bannerbuzz alternative page covers banners and signage.
Can I use my existing designs when switching to 4OVER4.COM?
Yes. 4OVER4.COM accepts standard print-ready files in PDF, AI, PSD, and other common formats, so you can upload existing artwork directly at checkout. If you want to start fresh, free design templates are available across every major product category.
